Which Herbal Method Should You Choose? Tea vs. Tincture vs. Glycerite vs. Syrup
When it comes to using herbs, one of the most common questions I hear is:
“What’s the best way to take this?”
The truth is, there isn’t a single answer. Herbs are beautifully complex, and each preparation brings out a different part of the plant’s wisdom. Some methods are gentle and nourishing, others are strong and concentrated, and some are all about making the medicine more enjoyable to take.
Let’s dive into the four most common methods I use in my own apothecary — teas, tinctures, glycerites, and syrups — so you can better understand when and why you might reach for each.
⸻
Herbal Tea – Gentle, Nourishing, Everyday Support
Tea is one of the most ancient and beloved ways of using herbs. Simply pouring hot water over plants might seem too simple to be powerful, but the truth is that water is an incredible solvent. It extracts vitamins, minerals, flavonoids, and many of the calming, digestive, and gently supportive qualities of herbs.
I love tea for everyday nourishment. Sitting down with a warm cup does more than deliver plant compounds — it creates ritual, slows you down, and connects you with the herb in a sensory way. The taste, aroma, and even the act of brewing becomes part of the healing.
Teas are especially effective for:
• Hydration: every sip counts toward your daily water intake.
• Nervous system support: herbs like chamomile, linden, and lemon balm shine here.
• Mineral-rich nourishment: nettle, oatstraw, and raspberry leaf are excellent sources of plant-based minerals.
They do have their limitations: teas require time and consistency. A single cup of chamomile might not change your sleep, but drinking it nightly can shift your whole rhythm over time.
✨ If you’re looking for a starting place, my Evening Garden Tea is one of my favorites for winding down at night, while Immune Boosting Tea shines during seasonal transitions.
⸻
Tinctures – Potent, Portable, and Long-Lasting
Tinctures are where potency meets practicality. By using alcohol as the extracting medium, we can pull out a much wider range of plant constituents — not just the water-soluble vitamins and minerals, but also alkaloids, resins, and volatile compounds that water alone leaves behind.
The result is a concentrated, shelf-stable remedy that can last for years. Just a dropperful delivers the equivalent of cups of tea — making tinctures especially valuable for acute needs (like an oncoming cold) or for herbs that don’t shine in water.
What I love about tinctures:
They are incredibly portable — keep one in your bag or cabinet, and you’ve got support wherever you are.
They’re long-lasting — often 3–5 years without losing potency.
They allow you to work with herbs that may not taste great in tea form but are powerful as medicine.
They allow us to extract the fullness of the herbs when done correctly.
For example:
Usnea tincture is a potent immune ally.
Echinacea is famous for supporting the body in fighting colds.
Blue vervain helps ease stress and tension that can’t be captured as well in a tea.
The main drawback is the alcohol base — not everyone wants to consume alcohol, even in small amounts. But a splash of tincture in water or tea dilutes the taste and reduces the sharpness of the alcohol.
✨ Curious? You can explore the tinctures I’ve added to the apothecary here. All of our tinctures currently are produced by Mountain Rose Herbs, this maintains our standards of excellent quality across the board.
⸻
Glycerites – Sweet, Gentle, and Kid-Friendly
For those who can’t or prefer not to use alcohol, glycerites are a beautiful alternative. Instead of alcohol, we use vegetable glycerin to extract the herbs. The result is milder than a tincture, but still offers a concentrated, shelf-stable way to take herbs.
Because glycerin has a natural sweetness, glycerites are especially loved by children (and adults who dislike the sharpness of tinctures). They’re also a good choice for alcohol-sensitive individuals or anyone looking for a gentler experience.
They’re not quite as strong as tinctures because they’re unable to extract the fullness of constituents that alcohol can, and they usually have a shorter shelf life (about a year compared to several years for tinctures), but they’re effective for many situations.
Some of my favorites:
Lemon balm glycerite → a calm-in-a-bottle option for kids (and adults) dealing with restlessness.
Elderberry glycerite → a sweet, immune-supportive remedy for little ones during cold season.
I see glycerites as the “gateway” into herbal extracts — easy, approachable, and perfect for families.
⸻
Syrups – Delicious, Comforting, and Seasonal
Herbal syrups are the sweet spot between medicine and food. They’re usually made by simmering herbs into a strong decoction, then preserving that tea with honey (or sugar). The result is thick, sweet, and absolutely delicious — making syrups one of the easiest ways to take herbs, especially for children.
Syrups shine in seasonal wellness. An elderberry syrup during fall and winter is a classic, but syrups can also highlight herbs like rose hips (for vitamin C), ginger (for digestion), or mullein (for soothing coughs).
Because syrups are made with water and sweetener, their shelf life is shorter — typically 1–3 months in the fridge. But they’re wonderful for short-term use and for making medicine feel like a treat.
✨ Want to try one yourself? My Elderberry Syrup Kits make it simple to brew your own batch at home with high-quality herbs.
⸻
Which Method Should You Choose?
Each method has its strengths, and the right choice depends on your needs:
For daily nourishment: teas are gentle and hydrating.
For potency and storage: tinctures are powerful and long-lasting.
For kids or alcohol-free needs: glycerites are the sweet, gentle option.
For seasonal remedies: syrups are delicious and soothing.
The beauty is — you don’t have to choose just one. Each has its place, and learning to use them together gives you a flexible, well-rounded apothecary.
⸻
Why I Love Having Options
This is one of the things I adore about herbalism: the creativity it allows. The same plant can show up in your life in so many ways. Chamomile can soothe you in a bedtime tea, comfort you in a glycerite, or sweeten your winter in a syrup. None of it is wasted — each method captures a different side of the plant’s gift.
So don’t be afraid to experiment. Brew the tea. Take the tincture. Make the syrup. See how the same herb feels in different forms and discover which resonates most with you and your family.
✨ If you’re ready to start, you can explore my handcrafted Herbal Teas or make your own Elderberry Syrup at home. Or check out our full apothecary here.